Bay Island Properties for Sale

Our website features the best Bay Island real estate search for homes, condo, and land properties available. It is the only site you will ever need! It is easy-to-use and updated by the official REALTOR®’s database every 15 minutes.

You can save searches, and get daily email alerts of new listings, price changes, sold data, and market reports. Our Interactive Map Search allows you to view properties on a map or refine your search by drawing the boundaries around the area you desire.

Bay Island Popular Searches

Bay Island Properties by Price

Bay Island Properties by # of Bedroom(s)

Bay Island Properties by # of Bathroom(s)

Curious about what’s happening in the Bay Island real estate market? Sign up for a Bay Island Real Estate Market Report to see what’s active, under contract, and sold!

Newest Bay Island Properties for Sale

$950,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 10645801 MLS

Live the good life on Bay Island! With your own dedicated boat slip on Lone Pine Road, you're on Broad Bay, the Lynnhaven River, the Chesapeake Bay, and Virginia Beach's finest waterfront dining within minutes. Tucked in one of the city's most beloved coastal neighborhoods, this expertly maintained 3-bedroom, 2-bath ranch sits on an elevated 23-foot lot in Flood Zone X — no flood insurance required, a rare and meaningful advantage that buyers in this ZIP code know to look for. Inside, original 1958 hardwood floors and dentil crown molding grace the formal living and dining rooms and was thoughtfully carried into the 2022 kitchen renovation — honoring the home's character while embracing what's new. The kitchen features quartz countertops and a THOR 36" 6-burner professional gas range with convection oven. The brand-new primary bathroom (2026) delivers a skylit bath with custom cabinetry, oversized tiled shower, freestanding tub, and a custom closet. A skylit sunroom pours natural light into the home year-round, and a fireplace with gas logs anchors the living room for cooler evenings. The systems are equally impressive: Weil-McLain gas boiler (2016), Trane HVAC (2018), whole-house Generac generator (2023), new water heater (2024), and an encapsulated crawl space with dehumidifier. Roof replaced 2020. Foundation reinforced with new beams and jack stabilizers. Two-car attached garage with new doors and openers (2020) — and an Ice-O-Matic nugget ice maker, because the good ice matters. Outside, mature landscaping abounds, including Star Jasmine over the pergola that perfumes the side entrance each spring. The hard-plumbed Weber natural gas grill conveys, white vinyl privacy fence, paver walks, and fully irrigated lot complete a yard built for Bay Island living. Golf-cart streets, neighbors who wave, and boat rides to dinner — 2504 Broad Bay is Bay Island life, fully dialed in.

2504 Broad Bay Road, Northeast Virginia Beach

$2,750,000

6 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 10644021 MLS

Welcome to a rare waterfront masterpiece! Exceptional & secluded home with over 5,000sq ft surrounded deep water with private boat ramp and 15,000lb boat lift. This 6-bedroom, 4-bath residence features an open floor plan with soaring ceilings. 1st floor primary has 2 walk-in closets, large bathroom w/double vanities, oversized walk-in shower and huge jetted tub. Gorgeous kitchen w/ double oven & 6 burner gas stove looking into the large great room that has floor-to-ceiling stone fireplace and large windows overlooking the water. 2 balconies, loft and built in sound system. Outdoor living at its best with a saltwater pool and stone kitchen. Set on a premier fenced in homesite with new bulkhead, over 3' at low tide, unmatched exposure and tranquility, this property delivers the ultimate coastal lifestyle—equal parts luxury, comfort, and unforgettable views.

2000 English Cedar Circle, Northeast Virginia Beach

$1,995,000

6 Beds ⋅ 4.2 Baths ⋅ 10642295 MLS

Experience elevated coastal living in this stunning waterfront home offering six bedrooms, including a first-floor guest suite with full bath, ideal for multigenerational living or hosting guests. The primary suite features a large ensuite bath and oversized walk-in closet. Outdoors, enjoy true deep-water access with a private dock and new 10,000 lb boat lift, perfect for boating enthusiasts. Unwind in the heated saltwater pool and hot tub, or entertain in the screened-in sunroom with built-in grill and bar. Additional highlights include a three-car garage with ample storage for vehicles and water toys, a dedicated theater room with sink and refrigerator, and dual laundry rooms, one upstairs and one downstairs. Thoughtfully designed for both everyday living and unforgettable entertaining, this home delivers the best of waterfront living.

2336 Spindrift Road, Northeast Virginia Beach

$1,500,000

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 10618398 MLS

Beautiful Mediterranean style home located on a canal in the very private community of Bay Island. Direct access from your backyard dock to Broad Bay and the ocean. Four bedrooms, three full baths. Master bedroom features a walk-in closet and private dressing area and a large master bath with sunken tub. Guest bedroom is located at opposite end of home with its own full bath. Large family room overlooking canal with lovely arched fireplace. Large kitchen with island stovetop and work area. Elevated back patio overlooking canal.

2200 Windward Shore Drive, Northeast Virginia Beach

Start Your Search

Some listings may be duplicated in the search results due to the co-mingling of listings from more than one multiple listing service. Should there be different listing information between the duplicated listings; user is advised to verify the accuracy of the listing information before making any financial decisions.